
I've been tossing around the relative merits of the Arizona Immigration Law in my head and have come to a few conclusions.
Ultimately, though, I have to say I'm in favor of it.
Now now, there's no need to yell and scream and make posters that say "racist" on them just yet.
Let's begin at the beginning, shall we?
There IS an illegal immigration problem. The KEY word being
illegal. Now, I live in southern California and, unlike many of the hardcore 'wrong coast-ers', know and have known many an immigrant, both legal and illegal. I can say that, for the most part, they have been no more or less honest, upfront, hardworking and peaceful than any native citizen I've known. So, there's no internal hatred or distrust of those with slightly darker skin than I.
But, unfortunately, this issue of illegal immigration tends to devolve into the two vastly polarized camps of "they're all bad" or "you're all nazis." Once again, we've entered the land of "With me or against me."
Like most other rational people, I think that ILLEGAL should mean something. Perhaps following the rules and doing things the right way is. . .well. . .right. But what to do?
That doesn't mean I think that all immigrants are bad. Not at all. I've come up against the tiny-brained folk who say, emphatically, "they should go back where they came from", never once having the mental requisites to think that their ancestors once came from somewhere else to here. The United States is, and always will be, a work in progress.
But looking at the Arizona law, the language is not as inflammatory as the sign-holders would have you believe. After a much needed clarification addendum to the law, people can only be asked for their 'papers' if they do something wrong. Which, to be honest, is perfectly fine. If I do something wrong, I'm asked for my information, and I'm just fine with that. I won't cry harassment of 'bald men in glasses' because of it.
The clarification of the law states that 'papers' are a drivers' license, ID card, or legal permit to live and work in the US. And when you think about it, how often are you out and about and DON'T have your driver's license? If I don't have it, I get in trouble for driving, as will anyone in Arizona.
The big issue with the law comes down to human nature. That is, the problem of 'profiling.' You can't legislate someone's morality. If an Arizona cop sees someone of color and decides that they look illegal he
could make an excuse, or "have sufficient reason," to check them out. This is an issue. But an issue, I think, that is much overblown, and I'll explain why.
Arizona, as with California, because of it's vicinity to Mexico has so many immigrants of the legal variety, that if you were to just start checking people because they looked mexican, then you'd never get anything else done. It's just not feasible to be as fascist as opponents of the law would have you believe. There's not enough time to do it nor is there the manpower to try to do something as silly as that. Logistically, it could not be done. Meaning, that the police, the vast majority ARE trying to do good, would have to actually do their job as specified by the law. Will there be abuse? Sure. But there's abuse everywhere and all through history. Failure to recognize that is asinine.
The LAW isn't the problem, what could be the problem is how it is enforced and implemented.
I'm fine with LEGAL immigration. Come on in, have a cookie. ILLEGAL immigration. . .not such a big fan.